Marx-Engels |  Lenin  | Stalin |  Home Page

From the transcript of the December plenum of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party of Bolsheviks in 1936.

From Comrade Kaganovich's speech. December 4, 1936
Questions of History, 1995, No. 1 Pages. 8-9

Kaganovich.... And finally, in 1934, Zinoviev invites Tomsky to his dacha for tea. Tomsky goes to him. Apparently, this tea party was preceded by something else, because after the tea party, Tomsky and Zinoviev drive in Tomsky's car to choose a dog for Zinoviev. You see, what kind of friendship, even a dog is going to choose. Helps. (Stalin. What kind of dog - hunting or watchdog?) This could not be established. After choosing a dog, Tomsky again goes to Zinoviev for tea. Regarding this tea party, Tomsky asks Rykov: Zinoviev invites me to his dacha. To go or not to go? Rykov tells us that he answered him: "You don't have to go." But Tomsky still went. (Stalin. Did they get the dog after all?) Got it. They were looking for a four-legged companion, since they were no different from him, they were the same dogs ... (Stalin. Was there a good dog or bad, unknown? Laughter.) This was difficult to ascertain at the confrontation.

... And Rykov, in response to the same question, declares:

“I had some cooling off towards him. We met in 1934–1935.”

And we know that he met with Tomsky not only in 1934-35, but even until recently; even when Tomsky was brought to justice, Tomsky asked you for advice. You yourself stated this at the confrontation. Don't shake your head. (Rykov. No, sorry, I didn't say that.) Please, I'll read it, I'll repeat what you said at the confrontation. This is absolutely correct.

Rykov. When I was at Tomsky's apartment in the spring of this year... (Voice from the floor. What year?) This year, 1936, he told me that during the period when we did not see him, he received requests from the Central Committee for Zinoviev's documents and during the same period he answered this... (Stalin. Did Zinoviev and Tomsky visit?) Me? (Stalin. Have you been to Tomsky?) In the spring of this year, but I have no news of Zinoviev. did not tell.

Kaganovich. Allow me to read. "... (Reads.) But I was against this invitation." You see, the mere fact that he asks Rykov, and Rykov says that he is against it, is this not a political act, is this a personal relationship? (Budyonny. Why didn't Tomsky ask Kaganovich if he could go?) Tomsky didn't ask you if he should meet Malkin or anyone else there, he asked you about the meeting with Zinoviev. You say that you categorically objected to him ...